New poll reveals how unrepresentative neocon Jewish groups are by Glenn Greenwald

Dandelion Salad

by Glenn Greenwald
Wednesday December 12, 2007 06:36 EST

(updated below – Update II)

A new survey of American Jewish opinion, released by the American Jewish Committee, demonstrates several important propositions: (1) right-wing neocons (the Bill Kristol/Commentary/AIPAC/Marty Peretz faction) who relentlessly claim to speak for Israel and for Jews generally hold views that are shared only by a small minority of American Jews; (2) viewpoints that are routinely demonized as reflective of animus towards Israel or even anti-Semitism are ones that are held by large majorities of American Jews; and (3) most American Jews oppose U.S. military action in the Middle East — including both in Iraq and against Iran.

It is beyond dispute that American Jews overwhelmingly oppose core neoconservative foreign policy principles. Hence, in large numbers, they disapprove of the way the U.S. is handling its “campaign against terrorism” (59-31); overwhelmingly believe the U.S. should have stayed out of Iraq (67-27); believe that things are going “somewhat badly” or “very badly” in Iraq (76-23); and believe that the “surge” has either made things worse or has had no impact (68-30).

When asked whether they would support or oppose the United States taking military action against Iran, a large majority — 57-35% — say they would oppose such action, even if it were being undertaken “to prevent [Iran] from developing nuclear weapons.” While Jews hold views on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict which are quite pessimistic about the prospects for Israel’s ability to achieve a lasting peace with its “Arab neighbors,” even there, a plurality (46-43) supports the establishment of a Palestinian state.

In the realm of U.S. domestic politics, it is even clearer that right-wing neoconservatives are a fringe segment of American Jewish public opinion. By a large margin, American Jews identify as some shade of liberal rather than conservative (43-25), and overwhelmingly identify themselves as Democrats rather than Republicans (58-15). And, most strikingly, by a 3-1 margin (61-21), they believe that Democrats, rather than Republicans, are “more likely to make the right decision about the war in Iraq,” and by a similarly lopsided margin (53-30), believe that Democrats are “more likely to make the right decision when it comes to dealing with terrorism.” They have overwhelmingly favorable views of the top 3 Democratic presidential candidates, and overwhelmingly negative views of 3 out of the top 4 GOP candidates (Giuliani being the sole exception, where opinion is split).

Contrary to the bottomless obssession which most neocon pundits and office-holders have with All Matters Israel, the principal political concerns of most American Jews have nothing to do with the Middle East. Thus, they identify “economy/jobs” (22) and “health care” (19) — not Terrorism — as “the most important problem facing the U.S. today.” Still, most American Jews agree that “[c]aring about Israel is a very important part of [their] being a Jew” — a common, innocuous and indisputable attribute that typically triggers noxious charges of anti-Semitism if pointed out by those who oppose the neoconservative agenda.

One of the defining traits of war-loving neoconservatives is that their unrelenting and exclusive fixation on the Middle East places them loudly at the center of any foreign policy debates. That tenacity — combined with their reckless exploitation of “anti-Israel” and anti-Semitism accusations as instruments in their political rhetoric and their corresponding, deceitful equation of their own views with being “pro-Israel” — often casts the appearance that they are some sort of spokespeople for the “pro-Israel” agenda or the Jewish viewpoint.

Manifestly, they are nothing of the sort. Even among American Jews, they comprise only a small minority, and their generally discredited militarism is widely rejected by most Jews as well. It is always worth underscoring these points, which are so frequently (and deliberately) obscured, and this comprehensive poll provides potent — actually quite conclusive — evidence for doing so.

UPDATE: Speaking of unrepresentative, fringe, war-loving right-wing neocons, here is the latest installment — titled “Jeepers Creepers” — in the perversely riveting and revealing melodrama chronicled in yesterday’s updates

UPDATE: The drama concludes just as predictably and lamely as they all do: War cheerleader beats chest (“Give War a Chance”). War cheerleader panics and cries for help over a “threat” compelling great “security” to protect him from scary things. Threat is exposed as completely non-existent, a by-product of the neurosis and paralyzing fear of the war cheerleader. Repeat endlessly.

h/t: ICH
FAIR USE NOTICE: This blog may contain copyrighted material. Such material is made available for educational purposes, to advance understanding of human rights, democracy, scientific, moral, ethical, and social justice issues, etc. This constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Title 17 U.S.C. section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond ‘fair use’, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

3 thoughts on “New poll reveals how unrepresentative neocon Jewish groups are by Glenn Greenwald

  1. Pingback: The End Of Israel? By Hannah Mermelstein « Dandelion Salad

  2. Pingback: American Jews on War and Peace: What Do the Polls Tell Us and Not Tell Us? By James Petras « Dandelion Salad

  3. Well, OF COURSE. These lunatics are a radical fringe of EVERY group that possesses any! Consider how many Christians are actually decent non-fascist people, for instance.

    As a convert to Reform Judaism from Methodism long ago — when Methodists were easily the most liberal Protestants — that decision reflected a desire for even LESS dogmatism. I care profoundly about their BEING an Israel, after history demonstrated appalling unwillingness by other nations (including the US) to receive those fleeing the Holocaust, but that doesn’t mean I approve of everything done by the present Israeli government. Few American Jews do, nor do a large number of Israelis.

    The notion that there’s some monolithic Jewish bloc driving our own government to neocon madness is anti-Semitism in convenient contemporary guise.

Comments are closed.