Tax Solution to Wretched Greed, by Joel S. Hirschhorn

by Joel S. Hirschhorn
featured writer
Dandelion Salad
January 30, 2009

By now most Americans have experienced extreme disgust upon hearing about the nearly $20 billion in bonuses given to people in New York City’s financial sector at the end of 2008. After sending the nation into the current economic black hole there is no way of comprehending the audacity of financial company executives in giving themselves and their colleagues shameful rewards for abysmal and disgraceful performance. Other than screaming and moaning about all this dishonorable behavior what should the Obama administration and Congress do?

Here is the solution that the overwhelming majority of Americans should demand: A law should be immediately passed that imposes a new special federal income tax of 99 percent on all income in excess of $500,000 annually for single taxpayers and $1 million for couples, starting for 2008 income. Call it a greed tax. Call it justice. Call it getting even for too many years of uncontrolled greed that has given the nation nothing but economic injustice and inequality, and given capitalism a very bad name. Call it a sensible way to raise federal revenues to help offset the cancerous national debt.

Considering that nearly all of the people who received the 2008 bonuses also received high salaries and even larger bonuses in previous years, and the many billions of dollars of federal dollars going into bailouts of companies, there should be no qualms about such a greed tax. For example, in the two previous years a total of about $70 billion in bonuses were received by these greedy financial sector elites.

Even outside the financial sector, executives also received obscene bonuses in 2008 despite terrible performance. The compensation research firm Equilar, for example, reports that the average performance-based bonuses for top executives, other than the chief executive, at 132 companies with revenues of more than $1 billion increased by 14 percent, to an average of $265,594, in the 2008 fiscal year, in addition to high salaries.

As just one of countless examples of greed, consider that the CEO of Hewlett-Packard, Mark Hurd, received $42.5 million in 2008 pay. He had received over $20 million in signing inducements in 2005. During his tenure some 40,000 jobs have been eliminated at H-P. And consider this nice little perk: In 2008 the company also paid out about $181,000 for his business meals.

And then there is the case of Robert Rubin at Citigroup. During his nine years there the company lost over $65 billion. What did Rubin earn? He pocketed $126 million. What did he say when he left? “I bet there’s not a single year where I couldn’t have gone somewhere else and made more.”

Enough already. Drastic action is needed to achieve some justice. With all the attention on the Obama stimulus plan based on spending money the nation does not really have or can afford, it is appropriate to use this proposal to raise more revenues. Tax greed!

[Contact Joel S. Hirschhorn through]


Is It Time to Bail Out of the US? – Astonishing Incongruities By Paul Craig Roberts

Match This for Stupidity: Taxing a House of Cards, by Walter Brasch

The Economy Sucks and or Collapse 2

5 thoughts on “Tax Solution to Wretched Greed, by Joel S. Hirschhorn

  1. This is about the most insane idea I have read in recent days.

    Let’s see: So we disincentivise people to achieve in order to “get even”, and that’s supposed to help anyone? Do you really think that people will take on the burdens associated with running very large businesses and have most of their compensation taken away?

    Your definition of “fairness” and “justice” is so warped that it is almost out of the bounds of reality. Only someone who is envious of people with greater incomes could come up with insanity to the degree as found in your post.

    Your solution to “greed” shows your own greed – you want what someone else has earned. Pull the plank out of your own eye my friend.

  2. Pingback: Obama’s New Bank Giveaway, by Michael Hudson « Dandelion Salad

  3. Pingback: Obama: A Strong Middle Class = A Strong America « Dandelion Salad

  4. Pingback: Wither Wall Street, by Ralph Nader « Dandelion Salad

  5. Good idea with a nil to large negative numbers chance of happening. Considering that Congress is largely bought and paid for, and the fact that a large percentage of Congress are millionaires and their own incomes would be effected.

Comments are closed.