Torture Memos Expose Dark, Imperial Presidency By Robert S. Becker, Ph.D.

Dandelion Salad

By Robert S. Becker, Ph.D.
April 29, 2009 “Information Clearing House

Abuse Pushed Hard To Justify Iraqi Invasion

This was not a happy week for the torture lobby, nor its defenders, derailing months of charm offensive by Bush-Cheney legacy boosters. A wary President Obama backed off attempts to defuse the torture parade – fretting over divisive investigations and hard-to-win court convictions. Public indignation likely surpassed February polling when 65% favored torture investigations, 40% criminal prosecutions.

Two releases, from the White House and Senate, disclose a premeditated Bush-Cheney torture program that postdated the original transgression, namely invading Iraq under false pretenses. This sequence dramatically reverses classic scandals, whether the Scooter Libby/CIA outing, Watergate, Iran-Contra or Clinton escapades. Earlier, the charade of cover-ups followed crimes, thus the countless perjury convictions. With Bush-Cheney interrogation, unholy torture was authorized to serve the unholy smokescreen clouding an unholy invasion.

Complicity with torture spreads like a toxic asset, impacting not just disgraced Bush lawyers or jailed Abu Ghraib soldiers (who, we learn, followed orders), but big-time officials, intell specialists, and agencies (CIA and armed forces). Consider pliant Democrats who went along and, like Senator Feinstein, condoned a string of Bush Attorneys General blind to waterboarding as torture. Political, let alone legal radioactivity won’t vanish by “moving forward.”

Warring Against the Constitution

What do we know? This scandal combines ruthlessness, contempt for law and magnitude: waterboarding hardly stands alone, one of ten abuses.

For me, the “torture debates” dramatize the dark side of an imperial presidency that made war on the Constitution, the separation of powers, and the rule of law. This scandal has legs by symbolizing the Bush Era, with Watergate-sized implications. Of course, big revelations that expose rogue White Houses once a generation bring good news, too. Eventually, the bottom line of governance re-appears: what real safeguards stand against authoritarian presidents gutting clear-cut legal statutes and decades of treaties?

Today, few buy President Bush’s celebrated lie from ‘05, “We do not torture.” Evidence mounts, inside and outside the government, that fixes this con alongside Bush classics: “Mission Accomplished” or “bin Laden: dead or alive.” Is Dick Cheney’s desperation not showing, sending dismal credibility to new bottoms? In contrast, President Obama, after a stumble, corrected any restraints on Attorney General Holder or Congress from mandated roles to uncover secret torture and determine remedies.

Torture Insinuates an Administration

We now have high confirmation that:

1) Torture spanned a government-wide conspiracy to ferret out spin (whether true or not) for invading Iraq; as Frank Rich summarizes this crusade, “If only 9/11 could somehow be pinned on Iraq, the case for war would be a slamdunk.”

2) Torture incorporated “reverse engineering” infamous, Chinese communist Korean War abuses designed to coerce false confessions for propaganda;

3) Torture remained U.S. policy for seven years, impacting Abu Ghraib, Qitmo, and black sites, despite protestations by the Pentagon, State Dept., and FBI;

4) Torture was approved and monitored by the president, V.P., and the Sec’y of Defense.

5) Torture secured no special intell, nor reliably deflected terrorist attacks;

6) Torture-induced confessions empower defense objections that jeopardize future convictions.

7) Torture, Qitmo, and Abu Ghraib fueled worldwide terrorist recruitment, anti-Americanism.

And more weekly goodies:

1) In total denial of last week’s revelations or expert testimony (from ex-CIA Inspector General, ex-FBI head) torture doesn’t work, the rightwing’s obsessive, pro-torture drumbeat continues, led by Cheney, oblivious to public opinion.

2) Law professor Jonathan Turley reminds us signed treaties obligate us to investigate all torture allegations as potential war crimes;

3) Favoring knowledge over punishment, Americans welcome disclosure, echoing John McCain: torture is “not about them; it’s about us… the things we stand for and believe in and practice . . . an observance of human rights.”

I expect torture inquests to become more non-partisan as Republicans bolt from Cheney’s rejection of “human rights.” Insider Newt Gringrich condemned torture years ago as violating “the foundation of American values.” The ultimate GOP icon, President Reagan, in 1984 rejected torture as “an abhorrent practice” and praised a century “of international measures against torture and other inhuman treatment or punishment.” Note, not just torture, but “inhuman treatment.” Of course, Reagan the WWII vet knew a Japanese torturer was put to death for waterboarding Americans.

More revelations are coming, soon from Justice on legal ethics, thus keeping the torture lobby on the run. That torture is “cruel and inhuman,” doesn’t work, marginalized national security, jeopardized future indictments, and fueled terrorist recruitment – that’s why this scandal won’t fade. The media is on board. If nothing else, we can now assess a terrible national disgrace, Abu Ghraib. Rethink those “few bad apples,” per Donald Rumsfeld’s blatant lie, having authorized prison brutality. What emerges is the entire rotten apple tree – the planting and force-feeding apples of abuse – farmed by the unholy trinity: Rumsfeld, his bullying pal, V.P. Cheney, and W., the gullible dupe blind to torture on his watch and any potential “war crimes.”

To read an earlier cry in the dark, see my November 2005 dissent, “We do torture”:

For more whether torture is legal:

This item was first posted on

FAIR USE NOTICE: This blog may contain copyrighted material. Such material is made available for educational purposes, to advance understanding of human rights, democracy, scientific, moral, ethical, and social justice issues, etc. This constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Title 17 U.S.C. section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond ‘fair use’, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.


Michael Ratner: If Obama won’t prosecute, Spain will + Allegations include ’sexual abuse’ and ‘beating’

Spanish judge starts Guantanamo torture probe + Torture Prison in Poland

Even In Cheney’s Bleak World, The Al-Qaeda-Iraq Torture Story Is A New Low by Andy Worthington

We Are All Torturers in America By Naomi Wolf

5 thoughts on “Torture Memos Expose Dark, Imperial Presidency By Robert S. Becker, Ph.D.

  1. Pingback: Triumphant Obama the Best Indictment of Bush-Cheney By Robert S. Becker, Ph.D. « Dandelion Salad

  2. What the unholy trinity of Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld, and their cronies, don’t realize or, worse, care enough to realize, that by their criminal acts of torture, they have raped the very moral soul of America, we used to brag about, which fuelled the engine of goodness America raised its children on, or so we’d like to think. They rendered all the passionate talk about ethics, morality, human rights, that we lecture the world on, day in day out, while setting benchmarks for humanity to follow with our human rights status reports in the world, mere empty, phoney and hypocritical bull. I suggest that, until we redeem ourselves, we should, at least for a while, just shut up about that – will just not look right. What a waste of soul, status, dignity and honor. These pieces of sociopathic work have lowered America’s head with shame, like nothing else and never before. There’s only but one way to cleanse America’s mired honor, so we can again look the world in the eyes when we speak of human rights, and that is to come clean on every thing. Tell it all and let the chips fall where they may. Let the law investigate and expose all the ugliness and crimes committed regardless of who were the perpetrators, and let it take its complete course in punishing those who deserve to be punished. There’s no other way, whether we like it or not, and political correctness be damned!

  3. Pingback: Bill Moyers Journal: Frontlines of Foreclosure + US Torture and Consequences? « Dandelion Salad

  4. Pingback: Anti-torture rally hits Washington « Dandelion Salad

Comments are closed.