Why Are Jews Liberals? By Timothy V. Gatto

Bookmark and     Share

[tweetmeme source= “DandelionSalads” only_single=false]


By Timothy V. Gatto
Featured Writer
Dandelion Salad
February 15, 2010

I was watching C-Span Book TV and they had Norman Podhoretz on, talking about his book “Why are Jews Liberals”. I felt as though I was in an alternate reality, like I had morphed into William Shatner and I was watching a monster on the wing of an airliner, but instead, I was watching a monster delivering a synopsis of a book.

I fully support a man’s (or woman’s) right to free expression, but I also feel I have a right to disagree. I know that since I’m not a Jew, my opinion counts very little to most Jews. Still, I feel I must state my disgust over this “intellectual’s” condemnation over his critique of the Goldstone (Who is a Jew) report. I was waiting to hear, as he bombasted the report, that Goldstone is a “self-hating Jew” but I don’t believe he did. Maybe in another Q and A he got around to it, but they didn’t broadcast the second Q&A.

I did see an older, frail man who identified himself as a Jewish doctor from the University academia say that he stood by the Goldstone report. In a trembling voice, he proclaimed that Podhoretz was dead wrong in defending what the Jews had done to the Palestinians in Gaza.  I applaud his courage as he stood up to this author who has seemed to turn his back on humanitarian principles to support the Jewish State that has embraced the principles of fascism.

Watching this show, I learned that the United States had condemned the Goldstone Report in Congress, with only 37 Democrats either voting against condemnation or abstaining. This should be looked at as a cowardly act by the House. It is up to the American electorate to find out who voted to condemn the report and to withhold financial support from these cowards in the next election.

I can’t for the life of me understand why Israel should not be condemned. They used white phosphorus against civilians, bombed the American University in Gaza as well as the U.N enclave. They used tanks and infantry with automatic weapons indiscriminately against women and children. There were 2,500 deaths with only a handful of those dead being Hamas members. It was a massacre against an urban area that has a median age of 14 years old.

I can only surmise that political reality trumps international law and compassion for our fellow human beings every time. I wish we could change this paradigm, but it has been with us since man first picked up a club and beat another human to death.  The more I see and hear, the more surreal things get. Oh, and by the way, I don’t make this stuff up.


Read Tim Gatto’s new book Complicity to Contempt.


Why Are Jews Liberals?


Norman Podhoretz talked about his book Why Are Jews Liberals? Doubleday; September 8, 2009. In his book the former editor-in-chief of Commentary magazine attempts to answer the question that he says he has been asked more often than any other during four decades in journalism: why are Jews liberals? He responded to questions from members of the audience. He talked about the evolution of liberalism and the changing socio-economic-political positions of Jews in America. He responded to questions from members of the audience. This event of the 26th Miami Book Fair International took place Sunday, November 15, 2009, 3:00 p.m., in the Chapman Conference Center of Miami Dade College, Wolfson Campus.

via [Why Are Jews Liberals? ] – C-SPAN Video Library


Final Vote Results for Roll Call 838

Michael Ratner on Israeli Apartheid

Israel: The Politics of Faith and a Land of Conflict

Goldstone Facts: The Real Story Behind Israel’s Invasion of Gaza

Gaza in Plain Language by Joe Mowrey

Did you know? Gaza

2 thoughts on “Why Are Jews Liberals? By Timothy V. Gatto

  1. Of course ‘jews’,descendants are not all zionists nor nationalists nor genetic war-criminals, But of course neocons are by definition born in the twilight zone with monsters on the wing.

Comments are closed.