A Socialist Response to the State of the Union by Billy Wharton

by Billy Wharton
Guest Writer
Dandelion Salad
January 25, 2011

Workers Of The World Unite!

Image by oemebamo via Flickr

Obama Out of Touch with the American People

Tonight’s State of the Union speech revealed just how far out of touch President Barack Obama is from the reality of working people in America. What a distance from the White House to the unemployment line. From the Rose Garden to the food pantry.

Tonight’s State of the Union sent the message one final time that the Obama presidency was and is designed to protect the privileges accrued by the richest 5% in society. Obama lived up to the characterization of him as a “hedge-fund Democrat,” a politician assigned the task of deflecting the real demands of the American people for a society and economy based on solidarity, peace and justice.

A Call for More Corporate Globalization

The President’s focus on “out competing” other countries, such as China and India, is a thinly veiled attempt to appeal to national patriotism made in order to disguise his desire to continue policies of corporate globalization. China and India are not the problem.

The problem is that people in the US are forced to live inside of an economy where the richest 5% of the population control 85% of the wealth. As a result, Obama’s claim to be creating a “more competitive America” doesn’t mean creating good living wage jobs for working people. Instead, it means continuing the same policies that are tailored to protect the wealth accumulated by the rich.

Democratic socialists have an alternative. Instead of playing to the business community, we need to get serious about creating a comprehensive plan for a full employment economy. This can be done through emergency measures, such as the creation of a National Jobs Program and through more long-term efforts, such as the funding of a democratically operated system of worker owned and managed cooperatives.

A commitment to full employment would put people to work immediately, thereby, relieving the skyrocketing unemployment and underemployment. The Cooperative Program would shift the national economy away from the financial and service sectors and toward manufacturing and production.

This democratically run economy would also provide a challenge to undemocratic capitalist organizations, such as the banks and multinational corporations. Once Americans experience democracy on their workplaces, a democratic socialist system of jobs creation will become a preferred choice for millions.

Americans do not need Bill Clinton “I feel your pain” platitudes. The Obama speech was full of them. We need jobs – good jobs that will allow us to feed our families and live lives free of the uncertainties of crisis economics. If the private sector won’t provide this, the public sector must be developed. Think of how much better we would be today if the public money that was poured in the banking system would have gone to create a full employment economy. Democratic socialism offers this alternative.

Obama’s Wars

On foreign policy, Obama claimed “that America’s moral example must always shine for all who yearn for freedom, justice, and dignity.” However, he failed to make any mention in his speech of his continued operation of the detention center at Guantanamo Bay. Guantanamo stands as a gross violation of international human rights. Closing this illegal detention center was a key claim made by candidate Obama during the 2008 election run. Today, even after signing an executive order in January 2009 to close Guantanamo within a year, it remains open and sends the message to the world that America is willing to violate human rights on a global scale.

In addition, not only has Obama continued Bush’s wars, he has lately taken to adopting Bush’s rhetoric. President Obama stated that, “We have also taken the fight to al Qaeda and their allies abroad.” In fact, what the Obama administration has done is re-enforce military occupations while extending the war into Pakistan through the use of drone bombings.

Just two days prior to the State of the Union Speech, the American military unleashed a drone attack in Pakistan that killed more than a dozen people and inspired a 10,000 person anti-drone march in that region. This was one of more than 400 attacks that have produced more than 1,500 casualties since 2008. Many of these people were innocent villagers summarily executed by a machine directed from the center of the empire.

It is time now for Americans themselves to put an end to American militarism. We can do this immediately by building a powerful protest movement to end the wars and occupation in Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan. And we can do more. We can develop a movement that puts the demand to cut the military budget by 50% at the forefront. To take the money used on war and the military and put it to work to create a better society for all.

This is the promise of socialism – a world based on peaceful co-existence in which global solidarity becomes the basis of human relations.

An Austerity President

Near the end of his speech Obama proposed cuts to the Federal budget including pay freezes and cuts to public programs. The President provided qualified support to the Deficit Commission who recommended sharp cuts to the budget “the only way to tackle our deficit is to cut excessive spending wherever we find it – in domestic spending, defense spending, health care spending, and spending through tax breaks and loopholes.” He pledged to carry out spending cuts on “…anything we cannot afford.”

However, these cuts are exactly the wrong direction for the country to be headed in. Austerity at any level of government should be resisted. Cutting Federal spending will have a spiraling effect on state and local governments who are already engaged in budget cutting. Federal support is the only thing preventing even deeper cuts on the local level. The Federal government should be strengthening these local budgets not forcing more cuts.

And there is one source that can be tapped into to fund not only local budgeting, but the creation of an array of necessary social survival programs. Simply put, the rich must pay. Over the past 30 years, America has experienced a class revolution in which the richest 5% of the country has monopolized an astounding amount of resources.

As socialists, we believe that Federal policy should be moving toward a truly progressive Federal income tax structure that targets the wealth accumulated by the super rich. This would allow the US to create a truly excellent education system – one that is free of charge from pre-K to graduate school. These funds could be used to make a green transition for industry by creating a publicly administered energy policy. And, the deep taxation of the rich could revitalize the country’s ailing transportation system by building a super-fast national train line, by creating a green jobs program for the infrastructure and by aggressively substituting clean energy forms for our current dependence on fossil fuels.

Budget cuts will not get us there. Appeasing the top 5% won’t do it. And trying to manage polluting industries through cap and trade will do little to stem the tide of global warming. Only a bold economic plan based on the principles of democratic socialism can create a truly democratic society that puts people back in control of their own lives.

What it will take

If Obama’s speech does anything, it marks the path that we need to travel as people interested in creating a free and democratic society. We cannot lobby our way to such a society. Voting for the lesser evil won’t work. And continuing to get by on less while bankers, corporate executives and other members of the elite enrich themselves is no longer tolerable.

To create a full employment economy, to end the war and shift toward a peace policy and to create a progressive income tax system, we need a democratic revolution. We need people all over this country to awaken from their long political slumber and realize that working people have to power to make history. Our demands for jobs, peace and freedom can begin among small circles of people and grow into a mass movement. We can move from tiny to victorious and now, more than ever, is the time for action.


Check out the Socialist Party USA


Barack Obama’s State of the Union Address + transcript (1.25.11)

Obama’s Collapse: The Return of the Military Commissions

Dennis Kucinich: What are we going to Sacrifice for War?

Chris Hedges: US wars to continue until its economy busts

What’s at stake in the global class struggle against capitalism

Socialism Can Save Our Cities & Small Businesses by Philip A. Farruggio

10 thoughts on “A Socialist Response to the State of the Union by Billy Wharton

  1. Pingback: Obama’s No Socialist. I Should Know. By Billy Wharton | Dandelion Salad

  2. Pingback: Lifting the Veil: Barack Obama and the failure of capitalist democracy « Dandelion Salad

  3. Pingback: Solomon, Nader, Cornel West and Chomsky: Building a Powerful Left in the U.S. « Dandelion Salad

  4. Pingback: State of the Union: Unnamable Politics and Useful Idiots by Joseph Natoli « Dandelion Salad

  5. Pingback: The Democratic Party’s “Far Left” Used to be Considered Just Common Sense by Steven Jonas, MD, MPH « Dandelion Salad

  6. Pingback: Chris Hedges on NPR: Government’s not a corporation « Dandelion Salad

  7. this system is not fixable by voting,”writing your congressman/wo or anything else except the majority of citizens getting the guts to stand up&actively protest/blockade/strike this evil/insane/heartless system run by 1%of the people<PERIOD!!!!! so i don't give a crap about what any politician has to say!!!!!!!!!!!!! hokahey/it is a good time to live

Comments are closed.