Looting is ALWAYS Wrong, Right? by Ed Ciaccio

by Ed Ciaccio
Dandelion Salad
Featured Writer
August 14, 2011

Capitalism Kills

Image by Resident on Earth via Flickr

The August, 2011 riots and looting in various cities in the United Kingdom have caused many proper politicos to make pronouncements about “senseless violence” and looting.  Looting stores of shopkeepers in the areas of the British cities where the riots took place seems not only morally wrong and criminal, but counterproductive, as well.  Most of these shopkeepers are members of the same ignored, disaffected, discriminated-against class and race as the rioters.  What more need be said?

If these rioters had looted Harrods and other Knightsbridge shops, or shops on Savile Row and Regents Street, where the upper-class Brits shop, that would have made much more sense because they would have been striking back at the most conspicuous consumerist symbols of the class which controls most of the wealth in the U.K. and enjoys keeping the lower classes “in their place”.  But the looting would still be morally wrong and criminal, because looting is always wrong, no?

However, when nations loot weaker nations, usually populated by darker-skinned peoples, that is considered “foreign policy” or “defending our homeland”.  See: Genocide of Native people of the Americas and theft of their land by Europeans, then the United States, 1492-1900.  See  northern Mexico, 1849.  See Hawaii, 1893.  See the Philippines, Cuba, and Puerto Rico, 1898.  See Nicaragua, 1912-1933.  See Iran, 1953.  See Guatemala, 1954.  See Iraq, 2003.  See Haiti, 2005. See Libya, 2011.

What about “senseless violence”?

The U.S. war on the people of Vietnam, North and South, who never threatened the United States,  killed more than 3 million Vietnamese and more than 58,000 U.S. soldiers, with millions more Vietnamese and U.S.  people maimed for life, and tens of thousands of them still suffering and dying from the effects of Agent Orange.  And what for?

The U.S. wars on the people of Afghanistan, Iraq and Pakistan, who never threatened the United States, have killed more than one million people and made more than four million refugees, with hundreds of thousands maimed for life, and tens of thousands of them still suffering and dying from the effects of depleted uranium used by U.S. and NATO forces.  And what for?

But, of course, this is not “senseless violence”, is it?

And taking revenge for the 9/11/01 terrorism by bombing, invading and occupying Afghanistan, now approaching ten years, in the process killing countless thousands of Afghan civilians, including many children, is “sensible violence”, right?

And when oligarchs, plutocrats, and corporatocrats  loot the people of their own country, such as with the Savings and Loan thefts of the 1980’s U.S.,  or the NAFTA betrayal of U.S. workers, or the 2007-08 bailout with taxpayers’ money of Wall Street banksters guilty of fraud, you don’t hear cries of “senseless violence” and looting.  These were all “business deals”, right?

And when these and other deliberate economic policies of a nation cause the majority of its citizens, its middle class, to have their income stagnate over more than 30 years while the upper 2% gets wealthier and wealthier as their taxes are reduced and wealth is transferred from the middle class to the upper 2%, as has been done in the United States since Ronald Reagan became president, that is certainly not “looting”, is it?

And when, because of these policies of redistributing wealth and income from the poor and middle class to the upper class, more than one million people per year in these “lower” classes not only suffer, but die as a result, that is certainly not “violence”, is it? See Analysis of Financial Terrorism in America: Over 1 Million Deaths Annually, 62 Million People With Zero Net Worth, As the Economic Elite Make Off With $46 Trillion by David DeGraw.

The current “austerity” policies in the U.K. and the U.S. will not only cause more hardships and more suffering for the poor and middle class of each country; they will continue to loot these classes and redistribute even more wealth to the upper class, all under the excuse of “lowering government debt” and “decreasing the government’s budget deficit.”  Meanwhile, these same governments continue to waste not only lives, but trillions of pounds sterling and dollars in endless wars for control of Afghanistan, Iraq, Pakistan, and Libya, with the U.S. now additionally fighting wars in Yemen and Somalia, and operating more than 800 military bases in dozens of foreign countries.

Of course, the worst violent looting has been going on since the dawn of the industrial revolution.  Industrial nations have violently, recklessly, and wastefully looted the earth of resources such as coal, oil, gas, uranium, and clean water, using methods which pollute the air, water, soil and seas, sickening and killing plant and animal life, including humans.  The recent B.P oil-spill disaster in the Gulf of Mexico and the destruction of mountain tops in Appalachia for coal are only two examples of violent, irresponsible practices still used which destroy and pollute our only environment while adding more fossil fuels which accelerate catastrophic climate change, a human-caused acceleration which already kills many more people annually than all acts of terrorism combined.  According to the World Health Organization, climate change already causes more than 150,000 deaths each year (see http://www.who.int/heli/risks/climate/climatechange/en/ ).  That death toll is equivalent to the combined death toll of fifty 9/11 terrorist attacks a year, or nearly one every week.

Yet the leaders of the nations most responsible for contributing to the human acceleration of catastrophic climate change, in North America, Europe, and Asia, have done virtually nothing over the last ten years to even begin to reverse this most serious threat to human existence.  They continue to support and encourage policies which only make global warming even worse while ignoring the many sustainable, alternative energy technologies and society-wide conservation measures which could significantly slow down the acceleration of climate change.  In their lust to loot the earth of its last fossil fuel resources, their latest debacle is the proposed pipeline from the Alberta, Canada tar sands to Texas.  Foolishly and irresponsibly supported by President Obama, his Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar, and most of Congress, this project is the latest example of how these leaders knowingly commit violence against our children and grandchildren by making immensely important policy decisions, greased by the unlimited funding of the fossil fuel lobby, which will create a hellish future environment with dismal living conditions due to global warming.

Let’s stop tolerating the hypocrisy of “leaders” such as David Cameron and Barack Obama who decry “senseless violence” and “looting” while they command military forces in the Middle East, Central Asia, Africa, and elsewhere which make the U.K. rioters look like people on a Sunday picnic.

Let’s stop passively accepting these leaders’  unrealistically narrow, self-serving definition of “terrorism” and “terrorists” being confined only to violent religious/political extremists who cruelly murder a few thousand people in a decade for political, ideological, and/or religious reasons while violent nations such as the U.S. and U.K. callously, intentionally cause the deaths of, no, the murder of,  more than one million people, including their own citizens,  for political, ideological, and/or commercial reasons during that same time.

Let’s stop tolerating these leaders’ intentional inaction on catastrophic climate chaos, inaction bought by bribes in the forms of corporate campaign contributions (or, as the five corporate Supreme Court justices view it, the right of “speech” by “corporate persons”) and lobbying by the fossil fuel industry.

Want to end looting on its biggest scale? Want to end terrorism?  Stop supporting governments such as the U.S. and U.K, and their corporate/Wall Street overlords with their sociopathic, profits-over-lives mentality, which daily loot and terrorize millions of people all over this planet, including their own citizens.

Stop voting for all candidates who refuse to oppose all the violent, murderous, suicidal policies described above, and support all candidates who oppose these insane policies.

Stop buying products from those corporations which lobby and bribe these sociopathic politicians and whose lobbyists actually write the laws of these governments so all this legalized violence and looting will continue.

Remind others to broaden their view of “looting” and “violence” to include the far greater daily looting and violence, financial as well as physical and psychological, committed by corporate-directed nations such as the United States, and the victims of this looting and violence in their own families and neighborhoods.  Remind them that our grandchildren’s future is at stake, and that we are responsible for the direction that future will take, by our action or inaction.


Demonizing the Dispossessed by William Bowles

Thuggery, Looting, Lawlessness… By the Ruling Class by Finian Cunningham

Riots in UK Could Forshadow Events in the US by Timothy V. Gatto

Analysis of Financial Terrorism in America: Welcome to World War III by David DeGraw

Noam Chomsky: Two Major Crises Looming: Nuclear War and Global Warming

You Can’t Kill a Planet and Live on It, Too by Frank Joseph Smecker and Derrick Jensen

This Time We’re Taking the Whole Planet With Us by Chris Hedges

9 thoughts on “Looting is ALWAYS Wrong, Right? by Ed Ciaccio

  1. Pingback: Riotgate: Dispatch from East London by Felicity Arbuthnot « Dandelion Salad

  2. Pingback: Keiser Report: Richard Heinberg: Energy in the current debt crisis « Dandelion Salad

  3. Pingback: Damn It Or Fear It, The Forbidden Truth Is An Insurrection in Britain by John Pilger « Dandelion Salad

  4. Pingback: The state unleashes the Dogs of Media By William Bowles « Dandelion Salad

  5. Dear Ed

    Looting countries, looting the poor and middle class and the transfer of wealth to the upper 2% can only be slowed by a voters revolution. I implore all Americans to refrain from voting for any politician who are Democrats, Republicans or Tea Party, next election. Everyone should vote but only for issues. This is the only kick in the ass, that these criminals will understand. Any one who calls themselves a progressive and still votes for Obama and company should be ashamed of themselves.

    Ed Dunphy

  6. Pingback: Farewell Content: Class Wars and Ass Wars By Gary Corseri « Dandelion Salad

  7. Pingback: Whistle While You Work with Michael Parenti and Greg Boozel (2007; must-see) « Dandelion Salad

  8. dear Ed,
    I agree with EVERYTHING you wrote except… I do not feel that condoning the violence and the looting of mom and pop stores will help to ‘ Win Over ‘ the majority of British citizens and citizens everywhere. As one who follows the precepts of Mr. Ghandi, i cannot support such actions by anyone. if we are to believe in the laws of karma ( as Ghandi did ) then what we give out comes back to us.

    i know how much of a phony and stooge mr. Obama is, and how disgraceful US and British foreign policy has always been. the key is for we who know better and care to influence our fellows to A) come out and do CONTINUAL PEACEFUL PROTEST on key issues and B) refuse to vote for ANY candidate of our 2 party/tea party con job here and the 3 ditto parties in the UK. that means even someone like the good soul dennis kucinich. he is doing the cause of progressivism and morality a DISSERVICE by staying in that corrupt party. Period!! he only LEGITIMATIZES the Democratic party as the ‘ Big Tent ‘ that it is NOT!
    great piece ed, except for that one issue where we may not agree . thanks

    • Dear Philip,

      Please re-read the first two paragraphs of my piece. You will see that I, too, as you do, consider looting of both mom & po stores as well as Harrod’s-level stores morally wrong.

      I am a conscientious objector who opposes violence, and an admirer of Gandhi and Dr. King for their firm but non-violent methods and beliefs.

Comments are closed.