Don’t Ignore How Others See Us by Ralph Nader + Nader’s Provocative Question

Dandelion Salad

Updated: May 2, 2013

by Ralph Nader
The Nader Page
April 25, 2013

Drones protest at home of General Atomics CEO Neal Blue

Image by Steve Rhodes via Flickr

In watching the massive media coverage and the reaction to the brutal bombing at the finish line of the Boston Marathon, the wise poem “To A Louse…” composed in 1785 by the Scottish poet Robert Burns came to me:

“O wad some Pow’r the giftie gie us/ To see oursels as ithers see us!”

English translation:
“And would some Power the small gift give us/To see ourselves as others see us!”

What must the “ithers” in the Middle East theatre of the American Empire think of a great city in total lockdown from an attack by primitive explosives when Iraqis, Afghans, Pakistanis and Yemenis experience far greater casualties and terror attacks several times a week? Including what they believe are terror attacks by U.S. drones, soldiers, aircraft and artillery that have directly killed many thousands of innocent children, women and men in their homes, during funeral processions and wedding parties, or while they’re working in their fields.

Here’s what they are thinking: that America is very vulnerable and ready to shake itself upside down to rid itself and protect itself from any terror attacks. The Bush regime, after 9/11, sacrificed U.S. soldiers and millions of innocents in the broader Middle East, drained our economy, so as to ignore the necessities of saving lives and health here at home, and metastasized al-Qaeda into numerous countries, spilling havoc into Iraq and now Syria. We have paid a tremendous price in blowback, because of Mr. Bush’s rush to war.

Why is the reaction to the events in Boston viewed by some as bizarre? Our president said, “We will finish the race.” Do we really think that the attackers are doing this to disrupt our pleasure in foot racing?

The attackers, be they suicide bombers over there or domestic bombers here, are motivated by their hatred of our invasions, our daily bombings, our occupations, our immersion in tribal preferences leading to divide-and-rule sectarian wars. Studies, such as those by the University of Chicago Professor Robert Pape, and former adviser to Barack Obama and Ron Paul during the 2008 presidential campaign, conclude that entry into paradise is not the motivation for these suicide bombers. What drives them is their despair and their desire to expel the foreign invaders from their homeland.

Another “ithers’ – admittedly a smaller number – must see a giant country going berserk with media, speculation, rumors, accusations, and random mobilizations of military equipment. There are enough of these younger people who must say to themselves, maybe it is worth giving up their lives for a place in history – to make a nation be fearful because of their rulers’ staggering overreaction.

Why give these contorted young minds, frustrated by what they perceive as U.S. attacks on their religion or their ethnic group in their home countries, such incentives?

Massive overreactions by the mass media (have you seen CNN’s frenzied, nonstop quest for every bit of trivia and speculation hour after hour?) crowds out coverage of far greater preventable loss of life and safety in our country. Other commentators have covered the lesser-known yet huge explosion at the West, Texas fertilizer factory that destroyed far more property and took more human lives than the Boston Marathon assault. But, the fertilizer plant explosion was corporate criminal negligence, or worse.

Every day in the U.S. there are preventable tragedies that receive no media coverage because they aren’t part of the “war on terror”, which has been crowding out stories that would have led to corrective actions to leave this country safer from the corporate predators within its borders.

Individually, many Americans intuitively understand the consequences of neglecting problems in our own country to engage in lawless wars and military adventures. Unfortunately, Americans collectively sing the song “que será, será” or “whatever will be, will be” because the big boys in Washington and Wall Street will always make the decisions. Be assured that they will often be stupidly harmful in the long-run to our country, and not just to millions of defenseless people abroad who have become victims of the collective punishment or random ravages of our massive push-buttonweapon systems.

In an impressive collection of excerpts titled Against the Beast, a Documentary History of American Opposition to Empire edited by John Nichols; the eminent historian Chalmers Johnson had this to say:

“. . .where U.S.-supported repression has created hopeless conditions, to U.S.-supported economic policies that have led to unimaginable misery, blowback reintroduces us to a world of cause and effect.”

At a first-ever Senate hearing earlier this week on the use of armed drones away from battlefields, initiated by Senator Richard Durbin (D-Ill.) and arrogantly boycotted by the imperial Obama Administration, Farea al-Muslimi, a young Yemeni from a village just attacked by a U.S. drone strike, gave witness.

Al-Muslimi said, “When they think of America, they think of the terror they feel from the drones that hover over their heads, ready to fire missiles at any time. What radicals had previously failed to achieve in my village, one drone strike accomplished in an instant: there is now an intense anger and growing hatred of America.” (Watch the full testimony here.)

As President Obama told the Israelis about the Palestinians, “Put yourselves in their shoes.”

In country after country, the terrifying whine of 24/7 hovering drones and the knowledge that special U.S. killing teams can drop from the skies at any time, creates a state of terror.

A brute-force foreign policy waging war can never effectively wage peace or sensibly engage in early conflict prevention or resolution. An illegal brute-force policy aligns itself with repressive regimes that crush their own people with American weapons and American political/diplomatic cover.

Jeremy Scahill, author of the new book Dirty Wars: The World Is a Battlefield, who has been in these countries and spoken with these villagers, says that our government has created unnecessary enemies and banked lots of revenge among these people over the past ten years. “This is going to boomerang back around to us,” he fears, adding that we’re creating “a whole new generation of enemies that have an actual grievance against us…have an actual score to settle.” Killing innocent men, women and children creates blowback that lasts for generations.

From these overseas regions, the message from the bombing at the Boston Marathon is that, until now, the high-tech buttons were only being pushed by the drone operators against them. After Boston they can see that other low-tech buttons can now be pushed inside the U.S. against defenseless gatherings of innocent people.

For our national security, the American people must recover control of our runaway, unilateral presidency that has torn itself away from constitutional accountabilities and continues to be hijacked by ideologues who ignore our Founding Fathers’ wisdom regarding the separation of powers and avoiding foreign entanglements that become costly, deadly and endless quagmires.


[DS added the videos.]

Senate’s First Hearing On Targeted Assassination By Drone Strike

April 23, 2013 C-SPAN

Military and policy experts testified on the the constitutional and statutory authority for targeted killings with aerial drones of American terrorist suspects overseas. In his opening remarks, Yemini youth activist Farea Al-Muslimi talked about the drone strike that hit his village in Yemen to kill a suspected terrorist, which also caused many civilian casualties.

watch via

Targeted Killing of Terrorist Suspects Oversea


Jeremy Scahill: The Secret Story Behind Obama’s Assassination of Two Americans in Yemen

democracynow on Apr 23, 2013 – The Obama administration’s assassination of two U.S. citizens in 2011, Anwar Al-Awlaki and his 16-year-old Denver-born son Abdulrahman, is a central part of Jeremy Scahill’s new book, “Dirty Wars: The World is a Battlefield.” The book is based on years of reporting on U.S. secret operations in Yemen, Somalia and Afghanistan. While the Obama administration has defended the killing of Anwar, it has never publicly explained why Abdulrahman was targeted in a separate drone strike two weeks later. Scahill reveals CIA director John Brennan, Obama’s former senior adviser on counterterrorism and homeland security, suspected that the teenager had been killed “intentionally.” “The idea that you can simply have one branch of government unilaterally and in secret declare that an American citizen should be executed or assassinated without having to present any evidence whatsoever — we should view that with great sobriety about the implications for our country,” says Scahill, national security correspondent for The Nation magazine. Today the U.S. Senate is preparing to hold its first-ever hearing on the Obama administration’s drone and targeted killing program. However the Obama administration is refusing to send a witness to answer questions about the program’s legality. “Dirty Wars” is also the name of a new award-winning documentary by Scahill and Rick Rowley, which will open in theaters in June. We air the film’s new trailer.


The World Is A Battlefield: Jeremy Scahill on “Dirty Wars” and Obama’s Expanding Drone Attacks

democracynow on Apr 24, 2013 – As the Senate holds its first ever public hearing on drones and targeted killings, we turn the second part of our interview with Jeremy Scahill, author of the new book, “Dirty Wars: The World Is A Battlefield.” Scahill charts the expanding covert wars operated by the CIA and JSOC, the Joint Special Operations Command, in countries from Somalia to Pakistan. “I called it ‘Dirty Wars’ because, particularly in the Obama administration, a lot of people are being led to believe that there is such a thing as a clean war,” Scahill says. He goes on to discuss secret operations in Africa, the targeting of U.S. citizens in Yemen and the key role WikiLeaks played in researching the book. He also reveals imprisoned whistleblower Bradley Manning once tipped him off to a story about the private security company Blackwater. Scahill is the national security correspondent for The Nation magazine and longtime Democracy Now! correspondent. For the past several years, Scahill has been working on the “Dirty Wars” film and book project, which was published on Tuesday. The film, directed by Rick Rowley, will be released in theaters in June.


Nader: “What will it take, short of a drone strike on a convention of constitutional lawyers?”

strugglevideomedia on Apr 27, 2013

Ralph Nader urged law schools to educate their students to challenge the Obama Administration of a long string of its constitutional violations and crimes. He was in the audience and made comments and asked the question above during the Q and A at a Yale Law School forum on U.S. drone strikes.


Panelists Answer to Ralph Nader’s Provocative Question

strugglevideomedia on Apr 27, 2013

At a Yale 4/27/2013 panel on drones Ralph Nader blasted law schools for not challenging their students to consider the Obama Administration’s long string of its constitutional violations and crimes. These are the answers of the panelists.


“We Continue to Miss the Main Issues” – James Cavallaro on Military Drones

strugglevideomedia on Apr 27, 2013

James Cavallaro of the Stamford Law School is the first speaker at the Yale Law school forum “Thinking About Drone Warfare” 4/27/2013


Drone Program Shows How the Constitution Has Been Totally and Completely Torched

strugglevideomedia on Apr 27, 2013

Atty. Bruce Fein speaking at the Yale Law school forum “Thinking About Drone Warfare” on 4/27/2013 (excellent audio, still picture for first 90 seconds then video is fine)



Q & A at the Yale Law School Drones Forum

strugglevideomedia on May 2, 2013


Glenn Greenwald on Boston Marathon Arrest: Will We Deny Constitutional Rights in the Name of Fear?

Two Obamas, Two Classes of Children by Ralph Nader

Deadly Raid: 11 Kids Killed in US Airstrike in Afghanistan

What Religious Leaders Want to Tell Obama on Easter

17 thoughts on “Don’t Ignore How Others See Us by Ralph Nader + Nader’s Provocative Question

  1. Pingback: Dear Pres. Obama: Domestic Catastrophic Risk Demands Action by Ralph Nader | Dandelion Salad

  2. Pingback: “Astoundingly Disturbing”: Obama Administration Claims Power to Wage Endless War Across the Globe | Dandelion Salad

  3. Pingback: Noam Chomsky: Drones Come Home To Roost + Jeremy Scahill: Dirty Wars | Dandelion Salad

  4. Pingback: Jeremy Scahill: Dirty Wars: Terror Begets Terror | Dandelion Salad

  5. Every one should take a lesson from the fall of the Roman Empire. they were so suprised when it was sacked by the visogoths lead by Alaric in 410 A.D. if a temporal city state Empire would last forever. talk about tunnel vision .

    • I think it may be inevitable. The big question is: what fills the void? We are living through an epoch of colossal adjustments.

      My own view is that the culturally mature communities with the best chance of sustaining some quality of life, will be those that embrace ecological intelligence.

      As Manfred Max-Neef explains so persuasively, the critical revolution must occur in the universities, that are microcosmic symbolic “theatres” ~ the intellectual engines of society.

      What good is a remote Mars rover, if the people deploying it are insufficiently educated in the fundamental principles of ethical survival on their own home planet?

      Little boys feed on adult men’s fantasies. High time the girls of all ages, had more say in our planetary destiny; and were granted the respect that is their due, for their greater innate capacity to protect (fight for) and nurture a sustainable habitat.

      • David , first off let me state that people are really getting hip to alternative food co-ops . they are here for sure. the writing is on the wall and people know it . Us musicians have done benefit gigs to raise money and awareness for the big eco-community garden here .

        the problem with the university approach –at least in the States is a lockdown of creative thinking-action in almost anything because of political correctness . i suggest working apart from those nay sayers.

        i am an adamant opponent to the space program because it is a big time waste of money . i even wrote and recorded a song called ”Mars can wait ”. Mars can wait ,, but we cant ! were the planet that must publish or perish . we are on the same page on this one !

        what will replace Empire. history shows us what does , and it aint pretty . Have you read ”the Delcine and fall of the American Empire ” by Gore Vidal ?

        • I think that’s great Rocket, and more power to your music!

          I get what you say about the tenured mob. I find it extremely hard to summon much enthusiasm for the sophistry that passes for learned enlightenment these days. That’s why I like Max-Neef’s approach. He takes it all back to Aristotle’s aeconomia, the loss of any true sense of value and traces all the bifurcations through to the present.

          Yes I’ve read most of Gore Vidal’s later stuff, he really called the bluff. I think its up to us not to be mesmerised by the false “singularity” of US exceptionalism. There’s plenty of old civilization still around if only we’d recognize it and nurture it; but also herald and celebrate the new.

        • David , check out the new documentary on pacifist Anarchosyndicalist Paul Goodman and his fusion of Aristotle and Jefferson . Amazing . you can find his interview on it on firing line –the old william f. buckly show .

          the reason why Vidal could see so clearly about the Empire is that he lived in Italy and knew his history of America so well . Vidal said that if the founding fathers were around when Abe Lincoln try to pull his dictatorship coup they would have hung him in the town square .

  6. It is tragic just how misguided the advocates of power have become. What is even more tragic, is that they will not feel the consequences, that others will.

    I think enormous billboards might help to get the truth across to those with scant awareness: in 6 foot high blood-red lettering ~


  7. It’s called blowback. Do the citizens of the USA and it’s ignorant leaders really believe they can just murder civilians around the world and nothing will happen? It’s the law of cause and effect in physics. Causality is the relation between an event (the cause) and a second event (the effect), where the second event is understood as a consequence of the first. Our war criminal presidents seem to think they act with immunity. Well, they don’t. Our actions have consequences. We reap what we sow. Newton’s 3rd Law of Motion. For every force there is a reaction force that is equal in size, but in the opposite direction. In other words, whenever an object pushes another object it gets pushed back in the opposite direction equally hard.

    • yup ! Nader warned us of Obama in 2008 when Nader said that if he gets elected it will be THE biggest con job in all of American History . not just one of the biggest …but THE biggest.

      i worked 3 times — 2000 , 2004 , 2008 for Nader to be President . i live in a stupin ass country that turned down a chance of a life time 3 times to vote in citizen number 1.

      and then they blame him and us for his running for president . crazy !

  8. Pingback: Barack Obama at the White House Correspondents’ Dinner 2013 + Conan O’Brien | Dandelion Salad

Comments are closed.