Stay Out of Syria! by Leah Bolger and David Swanson

Hands off Iran and Syria

Image by Eman Jueid for Aslan Media via Flickr

by Leah Bolger and David Swanson
Writer, Dandelion Salad
http://greenshadowcabinet.us
May 5, 2013

Statement of Leah Bolger, Secretary of Defense and David Swanson, Secretary of Peace, of the Foreign Affairs Branch of the Green Shadow Cabinet:

The Obama administration has seemingly painted itself into yet another military corner by announcing that use of chemical weapons by Syria would constitute a red line that would mandate military action on the part of the United States. Now we are hearing reports that the red line may have been crossed, and some prominent officials are calling for the U.S. to step up its aid to the rebels and/or impose a no-fly zone. Proponents of military action such as Secretary of State John Kerry and hawkish Senator John McCain seem to think that the U.S. can sort out the “good guys” in the Syrian civil war, and use U.S. military assets to help the rebels take down the Assad government.

U.S. military involvement in Syria could only make things worse. Syria does not need a “no fly” zone. It needs a “no weaponizing” zone. The White House and its allies need to stop arming one side of a civil war, and to persuade Russia to stop arming the other. Further escalating the violence will result in nothing that could outweigh the damage of that violence.

The Netanyahu government in Israel has just raised the ante in this precarious situation by conducting air-to-ground missile attacks against Syria, undoubtedly with the tacit approval of the United States. Allowing Israel to attack Syria without consequences is not only the sanctioning of a crime; it also allows momentum to develop for greater violence and pushes peaceful resolution further out of reach. Diplomacy must be actively pursued before it is too late.

Further military interference in Syria would be a disastrous decision in important ways. For one thing, it is not at all clear if chemical weapons have been used, and if so, by which side. U.S. media has a tendency to turn conjecture into accepted fact merely by repeating it. Furthermore, the U.S. military has itself used  and continues to use chemical and nuclear weapons — Agent Orange and napalm in Vietnam and white phosphorus and depleted uranium weapons in Iraq and Afghanistan. The ongoing hypocrisy of U.S. policy and practice in this regard undermines our nation’s international moral and legal position.

Secondly, there are few if any “good guys” among the combatants in Syria. Because the White House has decided that regime change in Syria is our business, Americans are now squarely allied with extremist anti-democratic insurgents—the same people the administration has deemed our enemy in Afghanistan and Pakistan. As it has time after the time, the theory that “the enemy of my enemy is my friend” will come back to bite the U.S. once Assad is out of office.

Those who hold Libya up as an example of the kind of military action that should be taken in Syria don’t understand some very basic concepts. Syria’s air defense batteries are located in urban centers, not like Libya’s, which could be attacked without causing a high number of civilian casualties. If the U.S. targets urban centers in Syria, global opinion will quickly turn against us. Furthermore, the Assad government’s close relationship with major powers Russia and Iran could mean that a U.S. attack would lead to widespread war. An escalated U.S. war in Syria would not be waged simply on American terms. Those who advocate for military action don’t seem to understand the global response to our actions.

But the most basic reason that the U.S. should not interfere militarily in Syria is because we should support self-determination. It should be left to the Syrian people to decide who will run their government. Overthrowing foreign governments is not legal, moral, or practical.  It is not a safe practice to encourage. In fact, in nearly a century of warmaking, there is still no example of the United States or NATO having “liberated” a country to beneficial effect. Libya’s violence is spilling into neighboring nations. Iraq is arguably in worse shape post-intervention than Syria is pre-intervention.

In the immediate term, the Green Shadow Cabinet calls on the United States government and the international community to provide humanitarian aid—food and shelter for those displaced, and assistance to countries that are providing safe haven for Syrian refugees. And the administration should invest in multilateral diplomatic efforts involving both Russia and Iran, as well as others, to push for a cease fire and an end to weapons shipments.

In the long term, we must win an international ban on weapons and war profiteering, which is a major factor in feeding the cycle of violence.

*

LEAH BOLGER is Secretary of Defense in the Green Shadow Cabinet. She is a former Commander in the United States Navy, retired.

DAVID SWANSON is Secretary of Peace in the Green Shadow Cabinet. He is author of War is a Lie, When the World Outlawed War, and The Military Industrial Complex at 50.

For website: Green Shadow Cabinet of the United States of America


David Swanson‘s books include “War Is A Lie.” He blogs at http://davidswanson.org and http://warisacrime.org and works for http://rootsaction.org. He hosts Talk Nation Radio. Follow him on Twitter: @davidcnswanson and FaceBook.

see

Some Don’t Pay Their War Taxes by David Swanson

US, NATO Using Proxy Terrorism to Achieve Neo-Colonialistic Goals by Finian Cunningham

Rick Rozoff: NATO Subjugates Europe, U.S. Duplicitous On Terrorism

US, UK Diabolic Lie: Syria Used Chemical Arms by Finian Cunningham

14 thoughts on “Stay Out of Syria! by Leah Bolger and David Swanson

  1. Pingback: The BBC’s Syrian Chemical Weapons Coverage: An Exercise in Imperial Deception By William Bowles (updated) | Dandelion Salad

  2. Pingback: David Swanson: Obama Nominee to the UN, Samantha Power Advised Violating UN Resolution on Libya | Dandelion Salad

  3. Pingback: Western States: A Gang of Arsonists Setting Countries on Fire by Finian Cunningham | Dandelion Salad

  4. Pingback: U.S. Hands Off Syria, Venezuela! | Dandelion Salad

  5. Pingback: Top 10 Western ‘Hits’ on Syria by Finian Cunningham | Dandelion Salad

  6. Pingback: US Makes Syria an ‘Offer it Can’t Refuse’ – Again by Finian Cunningham | Dandelion Salad

  7. Pingback: Western, Saudi Terror Hits Syria, Iraq by Finian Cunningham | Dandelion Salad

  8. Pingback: Cannibalizing Syria: The West to Blame by Finian Cunningham | Dandelion Salad

  9. Pingback: Barack Obama’s Message — Continuation of the National Emergency with respect to the Actions of the Government of Syria | Dandelion Salad

  10. Thanks to the Authors for telling it like it is. Hopefully more people will wake up to the crimes being committed by the western/NATO governments.

  11. Hurrah! You’ve outlined a course of action that a sane administration would pursue, plausible steps to address the issues without a caveman’s mentality… but how do you deal with the many-headed hydra of a corporatized military economy with a head of state serving the interests of the military industry and wealthy? We are dealing with evil people with evil intent who intend to flame conflicts into a mighty conflagration, an insanity so far-reaching that it is hard to grasp. And so threatening that the voice of reason is easily brushed aside by those in power.

    • I think that HOW is by reaching critical mass of people who understand what’s actually going on and refuse to stand for it any more. When the threat to the warmongers exceeds the payoff, they will have to deal with us one way or another.

    • Ariel , Gandhi’s strategy of ”non cooperation ”. we just don’t cooperate. period . we remain a non interventionist nation like the founding fathers wrote about . pure and complete isolation .

      it is the CIA that gets us into all this mayhem anyway . dissolve them , and that is a first step .

Comments are closed.