by David Swanson
Writer, Dandelion Salad
November 26, 2013
When Barack Obama became president, there were 32,000 U.S. troops in Afghanistan. He escalated to over 100,000 troops, plus contractors. Now there are 47,000 troops these five years later. Measured in financial cost, or death and destruction, Afghanistan is more President Obama’s war than President Bush’s. Now the White House is trying to keep troops in Afghanistan until “2024 and beyond.”
Afghan President Hamid Karzai is refusing to sign the deal. Here is his list of concerns. He’d like the U.S. to stop killing civilians and stop kicking in people’s doors at night. He’d like the U.S. to engage in peace negotiations. He’d like innocent Afghan prisoners freed from Guantanamo. And he’d like the U.S. not to sabotage the April 2014 Afghan elections. Whatever we think of Karzai’s legacy — my own appraisal is unprintable — these are perfectly reasonable demands.
Iran and Pakistan oppose keeping nine major U.S. military bases in Afghanistan, some of them on the borders of their nations, until the end of time. U.S. officials threaten war on Iran with great regularity, the new agreement notwithstanding. U.S. missiles already hit Pakistan in a steady stream. These two nations’ concerns seem as reasonable as Karzai’s.
The U.S. public has been telling pollsters we want all U.S. troops out of Afghanistan “as soon as possible” for years and years. We’re spending $10 million per hour making ourselves less safe and more hated. The chief cause of death for U.S. troops in this mad operation is suicide.
When the U.S. troops left Iraq, it remained a living hell, as Libya is now too. But the disaster that Iraq is does not approach what it was during the occupation. Much less has Iraq grown dramatically worse post-occupation, as we were warned for years by those advocating continued warfare.
Humanitarian aid to Afghanistan — or to the entire world, for that matter, including our own country — would cost a fraction of what we spend on wars and war preparations, and would make us the most beloved nation on earth. I bet we’d favor that course if asked. We were asked on Syria, and we told pollsters we favored aid, not missiles.
We stopped the missiles. Congress members in both houses and parties said they heard from more people, more passionately, and more one-sidedly than ever before. But we didn’t stop the guns that we opposed even more than the missiles in polls. The CIA shipped the guns to the fighters without asking us or the Congress. And Syrians didn’t get the aid that we favored.
We aren’t asked about the drone strikes. We aren’t asked about most military operations. And we aren’t being asked about Afghanistan. Nor is Congress asserting its power to decide. This state of affairs suggests that we haven’t learned our lesson from the Syrian Missile Crisis. Fewer than one percent of us flooded Congress and the media with our voices, and we had a tremendous impact. The lesson we should learn is that we can do that again and again with each new war proposal.
What if two percent of us called, emailed, visited, protested, rallied, spoke-out, educated, and non-violently resisted 10 more years in Afghanistan? We’d have invented a new disease. They’d replace the Vietnam Syndrome with the Afghanistan Syndrome. Politicians would conclude that the U.S. public was just not going to stand for any more wars. Only reluctantly would they try to sneak the next one past us.
Or we could sit back and keep quiet while a Nobel Peace Prize winner drags a war he’s “ending” out for another decade, establishing that there’s very little in the way of warmaking outrages that we won’t allow them to roll right over us.
David Swanson‘s books include “War Is A Lie.” He blogs at http://davidswanson.org and http://warisacrime.org and works for http://rootsaction.org. He hosts Talk Nation Radio. Follow him on Twitter: @davidcnswanson and FaceBook.
Torture on Tape: Disturbing Video Shows U.S. Special Forces Observing Brutal Afghan Interrogation
Empire Under Obama, Part 4: Counterinsurgency, Death Squads, and the Population as the Target by Andrew Gavin Marshall
Rick Rozoff: Time To Look At Human Dimension As Afghan War Enters Thirteenth Year
Malalai Joya: The Hypocrisy of the U.S. Government + Chomsky Scorns So-Called “Humanitarian Intervention” + The Afghan Peace Volunteers and Luke Nephew: Rap Against Impunity as the Afghan War Turns 12
Pingback: 17 Years of Getting Afghanistan Completely Wrong by David Swanson – Dandelion Salad
Pingback: A Call for Borderfree Skype or Telephone Connections with the Afghan Peace Volunteers | Dandelion Salad
Pingback: Building a Global Movement to End All War by David Swanson | Dandelion Salad
Pingback: Robert Gates Conceals Real Story of “Gaming” Obama on Afghan War by Gareth Porter | Dandelion Salad
Pingback: David Swanson: Lies and War, Part 1 | Dandelion Salad
Pingback: Who’s Excited About Another Decade in Afghanistan? | Dandelion Salad
Pingback: At least 13 Afghan civilians killed, including Hashim (8) and Zukoom (9) | Dandelion Salad
The troops are there to oversee the poppy crop, to be distributed in America, as heroin, the police in America are intent on punishing those who are involved with this other than the distributors at the top, which are organizations such as the CIA, money is then made by the addicts being incarceration, for some.
America is fast going down hill as a result of this type of organizational crime by American establishment,
Bearing in mind the British intoxicated China, as a tool of conquest, that is opium, strange the culture is administering this drug to its own people, a sign America has lost its way within the compass of morality.
It seems quite obvious that US foreign policy learned nothing from Vietnam or our many other debacles. We need to get out and stay out of other’s countries and quit trying to run (into the ground) the rest of the world. It is also obvious that we can’t even take care of the problems we face at home.