Oxford Union Snowden Debate with Chris Hedges: Moral Courage and Disobedience To Higher Authority Even At The Risk Of Persecution


Image by askyog via Flickr

Dandelion Salad

with Chris Hedges

replaced video Aug. 27, 2014

LeakSourceTV2 Mar 26, 2014


The Oxford Union’s 6th debate was a passionate affair, with speeches focusing on whether whistleblowing constitutes treason or a call for justice, and whether Edward Snowden, the now-famous source of the files that revealed the National Security Agency global data-tapping programme, merits the title “hero.”

OxfordUnion on Mar 21, 2014



See also: Union Debate: “This House Would call Edward Snowden a hero”

“Chris Hedges, a long-time journalist with the New York Times, opened for the proposition. Hedges said that a hero “shows moral courage and disobedience to higher authority even at the risk of persecution” and drew parallels between Snowden and soldiers who stopped the My Lai massacre in Vietnam. Hedges stated: “There is no free press without the ability of newspapers to protect the confidentiality of their sources” and “the relationship of tracking and being tracked by the state is the relationship between a master and a slave.” He ridiculed the NSA for collecting data on “the UN Secretary General, cardinals at the papal conclave, American companies, and NSA agents’ ex-lovers.””


Edward Snowden: Here’s How We Take Back The Internet

Edward Snowden and Julian Assange at SXSW

The Day We Fight Back: The Hacker Wars (featuring Chris Hedges) + Omnipotent #WaveOfAction: Be The Change

#NSA Headquarters Could Go Dark if Bill Passes in Maryland + Utah Lawmaker Moves To Cut Off Water For Massive NSA Data Storage Facility

Edward Snowden: There’s no saving an intelligence community that believes it can lie to the public and the legislators + Transcript

14 responses to “Oxford Union Snowden Debate with Chris Hedges: Moral Courage and Disobedience To Higher Authority Even At The Risk Of Persecution

  1. Pingback: Chris Hedges: There are No Winners When People Don’t Know the Truth | Dandelion Salad

  2. Pingback: Glenn Greenwald and Laura Poitras: This Award Is For Snowden + We Won’t Succumb to Threats | Dandelion Salad

  3. Pingback: Chris Hedges: The New Global Neo-feudalism Society (Q&A) | Dandelion Salad

  4. Pingback: Edward Snowden to EU: No Legal Means Exist To Challenge Mass Surveillance | Dandelion Salad

  5. Pingback: Chris Hedges: Our Only Hope Will Come Through Rebellion | Dandelion Salad

  6. Pingback: Ralph Nader Radio: Wall Street Criminals, the CIA, Fukushima and March Madness | Dandelion Salad

  7. It is easy to say that we should all be ready for jail or worse in the defence of freedom. However, those with families, children, two or more jobs etc. are hardly in a position to take such risks unless the forces of progress organise on a much bigger and better scale. The occupy movement was a good start.

  8. Glen Greenwald has yet to release the remainder of the Snowden files. Does anyone know why he is sitting on those files instead of releasing all of them? Thank you.

  9. And so far, none of the perpetrators have seen the inside of a jail cell. Why? Will they ever?

  10. Snowden, correctly is a hero, in giving the world the truth as to what the establishment is committed to, that is covert and undesirable probing and infringements of peoples private lives, we have to look more closely at who the government is and whose interests they are all part of, as we can see the persecution of Assad, by the British police who are colluding with deviant institutes such as governments who have interests other than the public good, as with Snowden, the same forces are at work, the establishment has been given orders from the 1%, super rich, this underground group has one thing in mind any threat or seen as, will be destroyed, the public has a duty to resist the conniving evil of this group who are at present given police protection at the cost to the tax payer.

    • David Llewellyn Foster

      Well, our world certainly looks exactly as you describe it dw.

      By the way, I assume you mean the persecution of Assange, even if it could be equally said of Assad, although this latter has certainly been a party (“knowingly” or not) to the most appalling human rights abuses by his own security goon-squads.

      My understanding is that it has probably always been thus, at least for as long as recorded events have been contrived. It is, of course, these “victors” and “rulers” who enjoy the privilege of public approbation through their “officially” approved narratives and those myths of power and prevalence these “histories” support and maintain.

      That is why the WWW is so crucial and revolutionary, simply because for the first time ever, it allows competitive narratives to flourish ~ throughout the world! ~ that open the discourse space to citizen participation & unrestricted free expression.

      It can be abused clearly, so hence the unequivocal necessity of responsible, documented exposure of government and corporate deviance and corruption.

      I think if we were to swap acronyms & change NSA to “SAVAK” ~ possibly adding “GG” (Goes Global) ~ for example, we’d rapidly get a clearer picture of the threat.

      Bravo to Chris !!

Please add to the conversation.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s