Christmas 1914: When Rank and File Imposed Truce During Imperialist War by Henry Hagins + John McCutcheon: Christmas in the Trenches

World War 1 - War of destruction

Image by Diego Sideburns via Flickr

Dandelion Salad

by Henry Hagins, Dec. 16, 2014
December 24, 2015

The “Christmas Truce of 1914” was a short-lived, unofficial lull in combat between two antagonistic rival forces, determined to exercise military, political and economic supremacy over each other in Europe and in the colonized world, to which these imperial powers lay arrogant false claim. One of the bloodiest episodes in human history, World War I was largely played out on the battle-scarred lands of France and Belgium, starting in August of 1914.

As an undeclared truce, started by rank-and-file soldiers on trench-carved terrain, the truce was seen taking place in sporadic locales all along the Western Front, on both sides. The truce is said to have been started first by German soldiers singing Christmas carols, followed by like responses from the other side.

However, by New Year’s Day of January 1915, soldiers of these imperialist armies had been forced to return to the senseless slaughter that left millions dead, missing, wounded and/or mentally scarred for life at its inglorious end.

We are virtually at the doorstep of its 100th anniversary. The Herculean efforts to oppose the war, led then by Vladimir Lenin and the Bolsheviks in tsarist Russia, remain applicable to this day and summon the critical need to revisit them with an unavoidable urgency. Contrary to the massive hype that is obsessively promoted in this country, it is U.S. imperialism that continues to threaten peace and human development throughout the world. Anti-war forces in this country are duty bound to help dismantle its deadly tentacles.

It is of paramount importance to understand that wars generated by capitalism and imperialism serve the class interests of those in power, at the awesome expense of the working class, which is used as cannon fodder to fight in them. In stark contrast, wars of national liberation become imperative when activated to free a nation or territory from colonial or neocolonial rule, after all other political efforts have failed or been exhausted. This was especially true in the 20th century. Nations under imperial attack today have the right to use this option when their sovereignty is severely threatened or violated. It is known as self-defense.

Europe’s two armed camps

Prior to the outbreak of the war itself, much of Europe had been divided into two armed camps, under an alliance system that required “backup” if any member nation was assaulted by hostile forces. “An attack against one was an attack against all.” For the sake of brevity, the two armed camps were comprised on one side by the Triple Alliance, made up of Germany, Austria-Hungary and Turkey, and on the other side by the Triple Entente, made up of England, France and Russia, with Serbia as an ally of Russia.

The immediate cause of war is attributed by some circles, but not all, to the assassination of Austrian Archduke Franz Ferdinand and his wife Sophie by Serbian nationalist Gavrilo Princip in June of 1914. Along with other Serbian nationalists, Princip wanted independence from Austria. The “fuse” had now been lit. By August of 1914, “the powder keg of Europe” had exploded. The carnage would last four years, at the cost of 20 million lives, ending on Nov. 11, 1918.

Horrors of trench warfare

The many hardships and grotesque horrors of trench warfare fed the nagging desire for peace by rank-and-file soldiers on both sides of Europe’s Western Front, on the eve of Christmas, 1914. Begun, first, by German soldiers singing Christmas carols, they were later joined by English, French and Belgian soldiers responding in kind. These war-weary combatants, singularly and collectively, made peaceful gestures toward each other across the devastated terrain called “No Man’s Land.”

Unofficial and short-lived, the truce was experienced all along most of the Western Front from Christmas Eve to New Year’s Eve. Some officers supported or tolerated the truce, while others called their troops “mutineers” and threatened them with death by firing squad if they did not cease fraternization with the enemy immediately. Soldiers from opposing sides openly shared cigarettes, cakes, beer, food, souvenirs and pictures of loved ones. They played soccer and held joint-burial ceremonies together, among other countless gestures of goodwill and comradeship.

The act of this fraternization is itself one of the most heroic chapters in the history of the working class, because it exposed the bankruptcy of imperialist wars. Workers do not benefit from them. And, in significant respects, it can be seen as a delayed reaction to what Lenin and those determined Bolsheviks tried to head off at the Stuttgart and Basel conferences of 1907 and 1912, respectively, before the outbreak of the war itself, when the revolutionary wing of the international workers’ movement fought to prevent its onset.

Even though the truce was of extremely short duration, the example the worker-soldiers gave fundamentally challenged the authority of kings, czars, kaisers and primer ministers to commit them to capitalist war. Imagine what a sustained resistance to this war would have looked like. One of the most effective tools for defeating imperialism is the refusal to fight for it.

I’ve a strong sense that our comrade Andy Stapp, the late founder of the anti-war American Servicemen’s Union, understood the power of this resistance in a basic and organic way. We still cherish his most heroic example.

To learn more about imperialist wars, must reads include “The Bolsheviks and War,” by Workers World Party founder Sam Marcy, and “All Quiet on the Western Front,” by Erich Maria Remarque, also made into a film. Another good anti-war movie is “Paths to Glory,” starring Kirk Douglas. I also recommend Wallace Terry’s best seller, “Bloods — An Oral History of the Vietnam War by Black Veterans.” — HH

Articles copyright 1995-2015 Workers World. Verbatim copying and distribution of this entire article is permitted in any medium without royalty provided this notice is preserved.


[DS added the video]

Christmas in the Trenches – written and performed by John McCutcheon

FolkFaves on Nov 16, 2008

From the archives:

Balls To War – When A World War Stopped To Play Football (Christmas Truce 1914)

1918 by Michael Parenti

The Folly of ‘Commemorating’ War by Lesley Docksey

Chris Hedges: It All Goes Back to World War I + Q&A

A Veteran Remembers By Howard Zinn (2006)

Don’t Enlist, But Don’t Just Take My Word For It by Lo

7 thoughts on “Christmas 1914: When Rank and File Imposed Truce During Imperialist War by Henry Hagins + John McCutcheon: Christmas in the Trenches

  1. Pingback: Christmas 1914: When Rank and File Imposed Truce During Imperialist War + John McCutcheon: Christmas in the Trenches – Dandelion Salad

  2. Pingback: Christmas 1914: When Rank and File Imposed Truce During Imperialist War + Christmas in the Trenches – Dandelion Salad

  3. Pingback: Christmas 1914: When Rank and File Imposed Truce During Imperialist War by Henry Hagins + Balls To War – Dandelion Salad

  4. Pingback: Christmas 1914: When Rank and File Imposed Truce During Imperialist War by Henry Hagins – Dandelion Salad

  5. Pingback: Merry Christmas To All | Dandelion Salad

  6. The rank and file could under dire circumstance see the folly of war much the same as the pigs who pass my house on a daily basis know they are the bacon of tomorrow as they squeal in chorus to God for remission who never answers prayer, the working class will wake up when they are in danger that is to late for redemption, when they return those who return are lulled back to their position of servility and any one who dares to leave the class will be dealt with, this is not meaning you become laundered at university and avoid scrutiny as to who you really are? by those who having been cleaned now vet those who desire to join the club?
    Only those who break the rules within the governance of the working class rituals such as refusing to eat the Sunday roast will understand the violence that will ensue by any deviancy from what is normal and decent? the working class had no problem with dishing out violence as also the officers must have shot many who never went over the top now unrecorded for also decency of being proper.

  7. Pingback: Balls To War – When A World War Stopped To Play Football (Christmas Truce 1914) | Dandelion Salad

Comments are closed.