Don’t Tell Me Third Parties Make No Impact! by Rocket Kirchner

Mural of workers holding placards

Image by Kheel Center via Flickr

by Rocket Kirchner
Writer, Dandelion Salad
Rocket Kirchner (blog)
Rocket Kirchner (youtube channel)
Originally published, March 7, 2016
October 9, 2016

If I had a dollar for every time someone told me that voting third party was wasting my vote, I would be able to go to a lot of baseball games. Having been in the trenches for many a year working hard and having fun at it for a third party or independent candidate, I hear the same old tired complaints from the uneducated as to how much impact historically outsiders of the two party system really make. This is not just my viewpoint but a long historical fact. We will get to those facts in a minute.

Cue up the green God Ted, as they say. So here is the basic premise: A third party comes along and says, “Either you adopt parts of our platform or we will take away that which you think you deserve.” In other words, no one is entitled to win an election, votes must be earned. However, the nature of power entrenched think that they have the right to our vote. That is part of their sell job. Another part is that they always say that this is the most important election ever, and if you don’t vote for us, you are note only wasting your vote but you are a spoiler and stealing our votes. Let us be good consumers shall we, and look at the merits of what they are selling.

How can someone steal votes that no one owns? They can’t. How can one be a spoiler? They aren’t. Either everyone is a spoiler or no one is a spoiler. This is the most important election ever. Oh really? Who says? Either every election is important or no election is important. Of course hereditary voting is really a problem and has always has been. I mean if the Democrats had Ayn Rand at the top of the ticket and the Republicans had Leon Trotsky at the top of theirs, at least 20% of the electorate in each party would vote for them. Now that is serious hereditary voting! But of course this example is a bit absurd I know because they would never get to top of the ticket anyway. But with 2016 turning out as it is, who knows? But I digress.

Here are the facts that I promised you in paragraph one. Since 1832 William Wirt running in the Anti-Masonic party garnished 7.8% of the vote, and got a grand total of 7 electoral votes. From there until the impact of Ralph Nader and the Greens in 2000, third parties have changed elections, wreaked havoc, and have forced the hand of the 2 major parties or they ended up losing. In other words, their impact is just that: IMPACT. Still not convinced? OK, then chew on this: 1860 John Breckinridge running for president on the Southern Democratic Party won 18.1% and ended up with 72 electoral votes. Teddy Roosevelt in 1912 Progressive Party won a whopper 27.5 percent ending up with 88 electoral votes, handing the election over to Wilson.

And it even gets more fun. Debs got 6 percent, Lafollette got 16.6 percent. Thurmond got 39 electoral votes, George Wallace got 46 electoral, and Perot got 18.9 percent. The 12th Amendment passed in 1804 was just waiting backstage for a few more votes. The ideologies of these candidates are interchangeable in context with what I am saying. They are all over the map. But see here is the thing, parties have lost over them. Those big parties that were smart adopted some of their platform. Those who didn’t lost. These are the indisputable facts. This is how democracy works, and anyone who charges that voting for a third party is a waste of a vote either is ignorant of these facts, or worse, they know them and are lying to us.

from the archives:

Trump vs Clinton – The Window of Opportunity + Transcript

Voting for the Lesser of Two Evils is Still Voting for Evil

The Punk Patriot: What if Trump Wins? + Transcript

Ralph Nader Interviews Jill Stein: We Need To Cut The Military Budget By 50% + Transcript

Resist Lesser Evilism

Ralph Nader: Dispelling the Myth of the 2000 Election (repost)

Peter Schweizer: Clinton Cash Documentary–A History of Corruption

Who Stole The 2000 Election? (Hint: Not Nader) by Eric Ruder


11 thoughts on “Don’t Tell Me Third Parties Make No Impact! by Rocket Kirchner

  1. Pingback: Abby Martin and Ralph Nader: The Rigged Corporate Two-Party Dictatorship – Dandelion Salad

  2. Pingback: Tariq Ali: Is Trump Any Worse Than Clinton? I’d Vote For Jill Stein | Dandelion Salad

  3. Pingback: Ralph Nader: The Two Party System Brought Us the Corrupt Political System That is Driving Our Country to the Ground | Dandelion Salad

  4. The entire US political set-up needs to be changed in a radical form. Two party-system is not democratic. The electoral college isn’t democratic either. Too much influence through money. Too much corruption. The MSM much too powerful – it should report, not cover up.

  5. I grant that Nixon looked at the votes Wallace got and crafted a strategy to capture those votes. I also just reviewed an article suggesting Henry Wallace forced changes to Truman’s policy. There is an interesting book on this

    • True Bruce . but had he not he would have paid the price . Henry Wallace had impact on pulling Truman one way while the Dixiecrats tried to pull him in another .

      Pat Buchanan ‘s new book ”Nixon – the Greatest comeback – really gets into how Nixon navigated the middle between Rocky and Goldwater. And did all those favors for the party and then cashed in in 68 . amazing insightful book on how to catch the wave of the vital center .

      as you know the thing about Wallace that is amazing is the electoral votes . but to me Perot is the big story Post Roosevelt – with a whopping 18.9 per cent in 92. Wow.

      the debate commission saw as such a threat that there has not been a third party in the debates since . George Farrahs book ”No Debates” is the best on the privatization of public debates agreed upon by Repubs and Dems because of the real threat of third parties .

      which gives credence to my article . this is something i talked personally to Nader and Buchanan about face to face when i met i them separately working with the Greens.

Please add to the conversation.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s