An Easy Test of Whether Democrats Are Faking It, by David Swanson + Abby Martin: US Retreats From Afghanistan: Truth Behind The Empire’s Defeat


Image by Bruce Berrien via Flickr

by David Swanson
Writer, Dandelion Salad
Let’s Try Democracy
April 23, 2021

When Democrats were handed the U.S. Congress in 2006 to end the war on Iraq, and they escalated it in order to “oppose” it in the 2008 elections, it’s possible some of them were not being completely forthright and respectful toward you, their loyal supporters.

When the Democratic legislature in California passes single-payer healthcare whenever it can count on a Republican governor to veto it, but never during Democratic governorships, or when the U.S. Congress ends the war on Yemen when it can count on a Trump veto but not when Biden is in, it’s possible that certain politicians’ expressions of concern for people lacking healthcare or people lacking bomb-free skies are less than completely sincere.

When Biden claims he’ll start withdrawing troops from Afghanistan by the May 1st deadline yet somehow not finish until September 11th, and thereby end a war that is mostly an air war, without ending the air war or withdrawing all the mercenaries, spies, and saboteurs, or when Biden ends “offensive” attacks on Yemen and “relevant” weapons sales, but the attacks turn out to all be “defensive” and the weapons sales mostly “irrelevant,” it’s possible he’s screwing with us.

But is there a simple test to determine when Democrats are faking it and when (if ever) they’re not? Is there an easy foolproof way to know whether they’re sincere or play-acting? How can we know, for example, whether these broken Biden promises should be blamed on Republicans, Russia, China, or — in fact — Biden:

  • A $15/hour minimum wage
  • Paid sick and family leave
  • Expanded voting rights, including for people convicted of felonies
  • Campaign finance reform
  • Free community college for two years
  • Forgiveness of student debt at public colleges and universities
  • Free college for families paid less than $125,000 a year
  • Universal preschool
  • A healthcare “public option”
  • A lowered age for Medicare
  • A pathway to citizenship
  • A ban on assault weapons
  • A ban on union busting
  • A ban on “new” fracking
  • A tax penalty for offshoring
  • The cap removed on Social Security taxes, and Social Security expanded
  • Vouchers capping housing costs at 30% of income
  • Abolition of the federal death penalty
  • Decriminalization of marijuana
  • Elimination of cash bail and of mandatory minimum sentences

Well, here’s the solution. Here’s how you tell whether they’re completely full of it. Go to bed. Get a good night’s sleep. Wake up in the morning and look around. Are they acting more-or-less like before? Or is the president and each senator and representative out making passionate speeches about the need to end the filibuster and the careers of Senators Manchin and Sinema? Are those two filibuster protectors being hit with any carrots or sticks? Carrots like public events with the president and cabinet members, media interviews, amendments and bills brought to votes, new committee assignments, campaign funding, trips on the president’s airplane. Sticks like public denunciations, ostracism, primary challengers, mocking TV ads, “moderate-confidence” “intelligence” “community” “assessments” of servitude to Putin, etc., etc.

When a political party wants something of one of its members, it usually gets it. When it doesn’t want it, it’s usually perfectly able to make its supporters believe it wants it, without actually lifting a finger to get it. What we need is simply to change this formula and check on whether there is any action behind words.

Has a single Congress Member committed to voting no on increased military spending? Has a single one of them introduced a resolution to end a single war? Has anyone introduced a Green New Deal more substantive than a “resolution” “expressing” “sentiment”? No, no, no, and this requires discipline. This doesn’t just happen.

But the Democrats rely on one thing. They rely on you to be an utter imbecile. They count on you to roll right over from electing them in 2020 to focusing on electing them again in 2022, with a focus on the icky Republicans and no questions about what the purpose of electing the Democrats in 2020 could possibly have been.

David Swanson is an author, activist, journalist, and radio host. He is director of and campaign coordinator for Swanson’s books include Leaving World War II Behind (2020), Curing Exceptionalism: What’s wrong with how we think about the United States? What can we do about it? (2018) and War Is A Lie. He blogs at and He hosts Talk Nation Radio. He is a 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019 Nobel Peace Prize Nominee. Support David’s work.

US Retreats From Afghanistan: Truth Behind The Empire’s Defeat

with Abby Martin

Empire Files on Apr 19, 2021

Abby Martin explores what’s missing from coverage of Biden’s announcement of the Afghanistan withdrawal.

WATCH our 2 new Afghanistan documentaries:

Afghanistan War Exposed—Part 2: An Imperial Conspiracy

Afghanistan, The Forever War—Part I: From The Killing Fields

Keep Empire Files independent and ad-free:

From the archives:

Ditch The Draft, Once and For All, by Rivera Sun

US, The Psycho Boyfriend, by Finian Cunningham

Medea Benjamin: Are Progressives Ignoring Foreign Policy? (Part 2)

Medea Benjamin: 10 Things Wrong With Biden’s Foreign Policy (Part 1)

Chris Hedges: Politics is a Game of Fear

Perfidy Meets Putty – Congressional Democrats Betray Voters, by Ralph Nader

America’s Political Illiteracy Sustains the Two-Party Tyranny, by Finian Cunningham

Top 6 Reasons Not to Give Biden Any New AUMF, by David Swanson

Abby Martin: Afghanistan War Exposed—Part 2: An Imperial Conspiracy

Abby Martin: Afghanistan, The Forever War—Part I: From The Killing Fields

8 thoughts on “An Easy Test of Whether Democrats Are Faking It, by David Swanson + Abby Martin: US Retreats From Afghanistan: Truth Behind The Empire’s Defeat

  1. Pingback: Afghan Lesson For Uncle Sam’s Running Dogs, by Finian Cunningham + Afghanistan: Who’s to Blame and What Next? – Dandelion Salad

  2. Pingback: Kabul has Fallen, by Kenn Orphan + U.S.-backed Afghan Government Surrenders to the Taliban – Dandelion Salad

  3. Pingback: David Swanson: It’s Absolute Hypocrisy – Dandelion Salad

  4. Pingback: Congress-Pentagon Flap Over Critical Race Theory: A Job for Critical War Theory, by David Swanson – Dandelion Salad

  5. Pingback: Biden Defends Ending a War He’s Not Fully Ending, by David Swanson – Dandelion Salad

  6. Pingback: Abby Martin: Biden’s Obscene Military Budget – Dandelion Salad

  7. One bill — the PRO Act — was not even mentioned in the article. A sad state of affairs when looking at whether moves by Democrats are serious or not. Labor reform (the PRO Act) is the one Act presently approved by the House that will directly affect most working people in the US if it becomes law. Other than that, a good article — what I’ve been saying for years now.

Comments are closed.